15+ Memorable Things to Do in Hill City, SD - Best Things to Do from a Local Couple’s Eyes

Tucked in the heart of the Black Hills, Hill City, South Dakota, is one of those rare places where the pace slows down just enough for you to breathe deeply, look around, and take it all in. Whether chasing the nostalgia of an old-fashioned train ride, craving lakeside serenity, or hoping to discover a downtown filled with artisan charm, Hill City delivers.

This isn't a tourist trap — it’s a town with a soul. And if you're wondering what to do in Hill City, SD, you're in the right place. We’ve created this guide highlighting the best Hill City things to do, from scenic drives and crystal-clear lakes to hidden gem restaurants and locally owned shops.



My wife Giselle and I have spent countless afternoons here, riding the rails of the historic 1880 Train, soaking in the beauty of Sheridan and Pactola Lakes, and wandering down Old Hill City Road to see where it takes us. And now, we're sharing it all with you.

So, whether planning your first trip or passing through on your Black Hills journey, this blog will show you all the unforgettable things to do in Hill City — no fluff, just the good stuff.

In this post:

• Ride the Historic 1880 Train
• Relax at Sheridan Lake & Pactola Lake
• Scenic Drives through Deerfield & Old Hill City Road
• Shop Downtown Hill City
• Eat at Giselle’s Favorite Restaurants
• Bonus Outdoor Adventures Nearby
• Trip Planning Tips
• Final Thoughts

Ride the Historic 1880 Train

If you only have time for one activity in Hill City, make it the 1880 Train. This vintage steam train winds through the forested hills between Hill City and Keystone, offering sweeping views, old-world charm, and just the right amount of adventure. It's not just transportation — it's a ride through time.

The train is a fully restored piece of history, with vintage coaches and steam or diesel engines depending on the day. The 20-mile round trip takes about two hours and passes through granite peaks, ponderosa pines, and spots you’d never see from the road. For couples, it’s nostalgic and peaceful. For families, it’s pure magic.

We always recommend sitting on the right side of the train when departing Hill City for the best views. The audio narration is full of fun facts about Black Hills history, gold mining, and early settlers — but honestly, we usually tune it out and enjoy the rhythm of the train and the landscapes rolling by.

Giselle’s Take: “There’s something romantic about it. I don’t care how often we’ve done it — I always feel like I’m in a storybook. Especially in the fall, when the leaves start changing… It’s like riding through a painting.”

Book ahead, especially in summer or during the fall color season. The station in Hill City also has a cute gift shop with old-fashioned candy, model trains, and non-cheesy souvenirs—we’ve picked up a few ourselves.

Whether it’s your first or your fifth visit, the 1880 Train is one of those Hill City activities that never get old.

Relax at Sheridan Lake & Pactola Lake

Regarding peaceful, soul-refreshing places near Hill City, Sheridan Lake and Pactola Lake are two of our absolute favorites. Just a short drive from downtown, both offer crystal-clear water, pine-draped hillsides, and a different rhythm than your average vacation.

Sheridan Lake: Cozy & Quiet

Sheridan Lake is the more intimate of the two. Tucked into the forest, it feels like a hidden cove — perfect for kayaking, paddle boarding, or simply relaxing along the shoreline. The water is usually calm, and the views are stunning. There are multiple access points for parking and trails, plus picnic tables and a family-friendly swimming beach.

We like to bring lunch and sit near the water, letting the day slow down. You’ll usually see locals here — it’s not overly crowded, making it feel like your little Black Hills escape.

Giselle’s Take: “Sheridan is where we go when we want stillness. It’s where you can have a deep conversation, read your Bible, or float silently."

Pactola Lake: Majestic & Expansive

Pactola is bigger, bolder, and just as beautiful. It’s the largest reservoir in the Black Hills and offers more room for boating, jet skiing, and deeper fishing spots. The cliffs and overlooks around the lake are dramatic, and there are even scuba diving opportunities in the old submerged town of Pactola.

There’s a scenic overlook right off Highway 385 that’s perfect for quick photos, but if you have time, we recommend driving down and spending a couple of hours lakeside. Like Sheridan, it’s easy to get lost in the beauty, but this one feels more epic.

Whether you’re in the mood for cozy and calm or big and breathtaking, a day by the water is one of the most restorative things to do in Hill City.

Take a Scenic Drive: Deerfield Road & Old Hill City Road

If you want to experience the Black Hills like locals do, get in the car, roll the windows down, and take a slow, winding drive down Deerfield Road and Old Hill City Road. These scenic backroads aren’t about getting anywhere fast — they’re about soaking in the moment.

The curves, the tree tunnels, the sudden clearings with mountain views — it’s not something you rush. These roads twist and turn like a ribbon through the forest, and it feels like each bend reveals something new: a hidden meadow, a grazing deer, a glint of sunlight off the pines.

Giselle’s Take:

 “This is my reset button. I love how the road twists with the land, and how the air smells so clean out here. It’s my favorite way to clear my head. We’ve done this drive at sunset, in the fall, even in the snow — it’s always magic.”

Old Hill City Road especially has a charm of its own. The 1880 Train runs alongside parts of it, which adds a fairytale feel when you catch a glimpse of the engine puffing through the trees. It’s also a great road to slow down and detour off the highway between Hill City and Keystone.

These scenic drives may not be on every “Top 10” tourist list, making them special. If you're wondering what to do in Hill City, SD, that’s peaceful, personal, and a little off the beaten path — this is it.

Shop the Local Boutiques in Downtown Hill City

There’s something special about shopping in a small town — and Hill City does it right. Main Street has art galleries, Western boutiques, handmade goods, and unexpected treasures. Whether you’re window-shopping or hunting for something meaningful, spending time downtown is one of the most down-to-earth yet rewarding things to do in Hill City.

We’ve strolled this strip more times than we can count. Sometimes we’re on a mission — other times we’re just soaking in the vibe. Here are a few of our favorite spots:

The Farmer’s Daughter

A local favorite for trendy Western apparel, jewelry, and stylish home décor. Think flannels, candles, and mountain-chic accessories that feel like they belong in a luxury cabin.



Giselle’s Pick: “Their jean selection is underrated. I always find something flattering and unique.”

Dakota Nature & Art

This shop is equal parts gallery and retail experience. It features local artists, pottery, woodwork, and paintings that genuinely reflect the soul of the Black Hills. If you're looking for a piece to remember your trip by, this is it.

Warrior’s Work & Ben West Gallery

A bold blend of rustic art and fine craftsmanship — from leather goods to forged metal pieces. It’s got a bit of an edge and is perfect for anyone who appreciates skilled artisan work.

Jewel of the West

This little shop is full of handcrafted jewelry and unique stones, many sourced from around the region. It's a great spot for gifts, souvenirs, or a special treat for yourself.

Bonus Stop: TurtleTown

It's not a boutique, but it's worth a visit. Handmade fudge, caramel apples, and old-school candy smell like happiness and nostalgia.

Eat at Giselle’s Favorite Restaurants in Hill City

One of the most underrated pleasures in Hill City is the food. Whether you're fueling up after a scenic hike or planning a cozy date night, this little town has some surprisingly solid spots. And when Giselle finds a place she loves, she doesn’t keep it a secret.

Alpine Inn – A Hill City Classic

Let’s start with the crown jewel. Alpine Inn is a local legend—a historic, family-run restaurant housed in a beautiful old European-style building in the heart of downtown. It serves a minimalist dinner menu: perfectly cooked filet mignon, a baked potato, and a crisp wedge salad.

That’s it. No substitutions. No frills. Just perfectly done. And to top it off, their dessert menu is enormous and deliciously over the top.

Important: It’s cash only and doesn’t take reservations, so come early or be ready for a wait. (Totally worth it.)

Giselle’s Take:

 “It’s cozy, consistent, and one of the few places I’ve ever craved even before we left town. Plus, I always feel like I’m in a little European storybook when I’m there.”

Mangiamo Wood Fired Pizza

Rustic vibes, hot pizza, and that wood-fired smell you can’t fake. Tucked off the main strip, it serves up artisan-style pies with creative topping combos and fresh ingredients. It's a great casual spot, especially if you're coming in from the lake or trail.

Slate Creek Grill

A go-to for hearty burgers, sandwiches, and comfort food. The patio is lovely when the weather’s good, and the service always feels genuinely small-town friendly—great lunch stop or laid-back dinner option.

TurtleTown = Dessert + Espresso Fix

Technically, it is more of a dessert shop, but it deserves a shout-out. We never leave Hill City without swinging through TurtleTown for handmade fudge, caramel apples, or ice cream. They also serve solid coffee and espresso if you’re dragging midday.

Eating your way through town may not be the first thing that pops up when you search for things to do in Hill City, but trust us — these meals and moments around the table make this town so memorable.

Bonus Outdoor Adventures Near Hill City

As much as we love Hill City, some of its most unforgettable adventures are just outside its borders. The Black Hills are full of scenic trails, iconic landmarks, and little surprises, making the whole region feel like one big outdoor playground. If you have an extra day or two, here are a few bonus ideas worth exploring:

Mickelson Trail Access

Hill City is one of the gateway towns for the George S. Mickelson Trail — a 109-mile path that winds through old railroad grades, tunnels, and breathtaking pine forests. You can hop on from town and walk, run, or bike into total serenity.

Mount Rushmore

Just a 20–25 minute drive away, Mount Rushmore is a must-see at least once. Whether you go during the day or for the evening lighting ceremony, there’s something surreal about seeing those granite faces up close.

Horseback Riding & ATV Rentals

Several outfitters around Hill City and Custer offer horseback rides into the hills or ATV rentals for the more adrenaline-inclined. It's a great way to cover more ground while getting up close to nature in an immersive and exciting way.

Prairie Berry Winery & Miner Brewing Co.

Right down the road near Keystone, Prairie Berry Winery is an excellent stop for local wine tasting — their famous “Red Ass Rhubarb” always gets a laugh. If you’re more of a beer person, Miner Brewing is right next door with craft beer brewed in the heart of the Hills.

Whether you're an outdoor lover or just like mixing things up, these experiences round out your trip and give you a taste of the broader Black Hills vibe. They're close enough to feel convenient, but exciting enough to make your trip even more memorable.

Best Time to Visit Hill City + Trip Planning Tips

One of the best things about Hill City is that it's a four-season destination — each season with unique beauty. But depending on what you’re hoping to experience, some times of year might suit your plans better than others.

Spring (April–May):

The Black Hills start waking up with wildflowers, green hills, and cooler temperatures — perfect for hiking and scenic drives without the summer crowds. Some businesses are still getting ramped up for the season, so check ahead if you're planning specific stops.

Summer (June–August):

Peak tourist season for a reason. Everything’s open, the lakes are warm, the 1880 Train runs multiple times daily, and downtown Hill City comes alive with festivals and events. It’s also the busiest, so book early for lodging and dinner reservations (especially Alpine Inn) if you visit in summer.

Fall (September–October):

This is our personal favorite. The fall colors on Deerfield Road and Old Hill City Road are unreal, the air is crisp, and the crowds start thinning out. It’s a peaceful and stunning time to explore, drive, and take photos. This is it if you’re looking for that “Hallmark movie in the mountains” vibe.

Winter (November–March):

Quiet season. Some places close for the winter, but if you're into solitude, snow-dusted forests, and cheaper stays, it’s not a bad time for a quick escape. Nearby Lead and Deadwood offer more winter-specific activities like snowmobiling or skiing.

Where to Stay:

• Cabins & Vacation Rentals: Tons of cozy options near the lakes or tucked in the woods
• Hill City Hotels/Inns: Like Harney Peak Inn or Best Western Golden Spike
• RV Camping: Several sites nearby with great views, especially in warmer months

Events to Check Out:

• Sculpture in the Hills – June art festival downtown
• Hill City Wine, Brew & BBQ – Summer food + drink fest
• Black Hills Film Festival – Features regional creatives and indie films

Whatever season you visit, you’ll find Hill City welcoming, walkable, and ready to surprise you in all the right ways.

Final Thoughts: What to Do in Hill City SD

Hill City may be small, but it has a way of sticking with you. It’s not just the views or the attractions — it’s the feeling you get while you’re here. The pace slows down, the air feels cleaner, and the little things start to matter again.

Whether riding the 1880 Train, wandering through downtown shops, or just driving with the windows down on Old Hill City Road, this town invites you to breathe differently. It’s one of those places where time feels generous and memories think easily.

So if you’re still wondering what to do in Hill City, SD, start with the simple things: ride the train, sit by a lake, share a good meal, and explore like a local. You don’t need an hour-by-hour itinerary — Hill City rewards curiosity and connection more than checklists.

And hey — if you fall in love with this place like we did, I'll be right here when you're ready to turn those weekend daydreams into a forever home (or at least a long weekend cabin).